Shaker vs Modern Kitchens: Which Is Right for Your Home?

Blog: Shaker vs Modern Kitchens — Which Is Right for Your Home?

When you’re planning a new kitchen, choosing the right style is one of the biggest decisions you’ll make. Two of the most popular kitchen designs we install across Kendal, Arnside, Milnthorpe, and Grange-over-Sands are Shaker and Modern kitchens.

But what’s the difference — and how do you know which is right for your home?

At Eglin Kitchens, we help homeowners decide based on lifestyle, architecture, and personal taste. Below is a clear comparison to guide you.

What Is a Shaker Kitchen?

Shaker kitchens are known for their timeless simplicity.

Key features include:

• Recessed panel doors

• Classic proportions

• Minimalist design

• Typically neutral colours

Shaker kitchens are ideal for homes with a traditional or transitional interior — especially cottages and period properties in the South Lakes.

✔ Benefits of Shaker Kitchens

• Timeless and versatile

• Works with both classic and contemporary interiors

• Hides wear and tear well

• Easy to accessorise with handles or knobs

👉 Learn more in our blog: 10 Common Kitchen Design Mistakes.

What Is a Modern Kitchen?

Modern kitchens are sleek, bold and contemporary. They focus on clean lines, gloss finishes, and integrated handles.

Key features include:

• Handleless units

• High-gloss or matte finishes

• Minimal ornamentation

• Integrated appliances

Modern kitchens work brilliantly in new builds, urban homes and open-plan layouts, bringing a streamlined, refined aesthetic.

✔ Benefits of Modern Kitchens

• Sleek, minimalist appearance

• Easy to keep clean

• Great for open-plan spaces

• Looks highly contemporary

Side-by-Side Comparison

How to Choose the Right Style for Your Home

Here are five questions to help you decide:

1. What’s your home’s architecture?

   • Older homes often suit Shaker kitchens.

   • Modern builds complement modern kitchens.

2. What’s your lifestyle?

   • Families often prefer the warmth of Shaker.

   • Entertainers love the clean flow of modern layouts.

3. How long do you plan to stay?

   • Shaker is timeless.

   • Modern can feel trend-forward.

4. Do you want integrated appliances?

   • Modern kitchens are ideal for hidden appliances.

5. How important is easy cleaning?

   • Modern handleless kitchens are easier to keep tidy.

Blending Both Styles: Transitional Kitchens

You don’t always have to choose one. Transitional kitchens mix elements of both Shaker and modern — combining warmth with simplicity. This style is perfect if you love classic character but want a modern twist.

Ready to Find Your Style?

Whether you lean toward Shaker or modern, the right design will reflect your life and suit your home. At Eglin Kitchens, we offer bespoke design services that help you choose a style that works beautifully for your space.

👉 Book a home visit and let’s explore what works best for you.